Clinician Emotional Response Toward Narcissistic Patients: A Preliminary Report
Accepted: March 9, 2015
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.
Authors
Patients with narcissistic personality disorder are among the most difficult to treat in therapy, especially for their strong resistance to treatment and several difficulties in establishing a therapeutic relationship characterized by intimacy, safety, and trust. In particular, therapists’ emotional responses to these patients can be particularly intense and frustrating, as reported in the clinical literature but rarely investigated empirically.
The aims of this preliminary study were: 1) to examine the associations between patients’ narcissistic personality disorder and distinct therapists’ countertransference patterns; and 2) to verify whether these clinicians’ emotional reactions were influenced by their theoretical orientation (as well as gender and age).
A national sample of psychiatrists and clinical psychologists (N = 250) completed the Therapist Response Questionnaire (TRQ) to identify patterns of therapist emotional response, and the Shedler-Westen Assessment Procedure-200 (SWAP-200) to assess personality disorder and level of psychological functioning in a patient currently in their care and with whom they had worked for a minimum of eight sessions and a maximum of 6 months (one session per week).
From the complete therapist sample, we identified a subgroup (N = 35) of patients with narcissistic personality disorder, and we found that this personality pathology was positively associated with criticized/mistreated and disengaged countertransference, but negatively associated with positive therapist response. Moreover, our results confirmed that the relationship between patients’ narcissistic personality disorder and therapists’ emotional responses was not dependent on clinicians’ theoretical approach (as well as their age and gender).
These findings are consistent with clinical observations, as well as some empirical contributions, and have meaningful implications for clinical practice of patients suffering from this challenging pathology.
How to Cite
PAGEPress has chosen to apply the Creative Commons Attribution NonCommercial 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC 4.0) to all manuscripts to be published.
-
Henriette Löffler-Stastka, Christian Sell, Johannes Zimmermann, Dorothea Huber, Guenther KlugBulletin of the Menninger Clinic : 2019
-
Federico Dazzi, Laura Fonzi, Mauro Pallagrosi, Marina Duro, Massimo Biondi, Angelo PicardiClinical Practice & Epidemiology in Mental Health : 2021
-
Elsa RonningstamJournal of Personality Disorders : 2020
-
Shira Barzilay, Zimri S. Yaseen, Mariah Hawes, Irina Kopeykina, Firouz Ardalan, Paul Rosenfield, James Murrough, Igor GalynkerSuicide and Life-Threatening Behavior : 2019
-
Diana Diamond, Richard G. HershJournal of Personality Disorders : 2020
-
Antonello Colli, Daniela Gentile, Valeria Condino, Vittorio LingiardiPsychotherapy Research : 2019
-
Mauro Pallagrosi, Laura Fonzi, Angelo Picardi, Massimo BiondiPsychopathology : 2016
-
Emanuel Jauk, Lisa Ulbrich, Paul Jorschick, Michael Höfler, Scott Barry Kaufman, Philipp KanskeJournal of Personality : 2022
-
Mara Villalongo Andino, Neil Hauenstein, Kasey Stanton, Matthew F. D. Brown, John A. RicheyJournal of Psychopathology and Behavioral Assessment : 2024
-
Antonello Colli, Annalisa Tanzilli, Ivan Gualco, Vittorio LingiardiPsychopathology : 2016
-
Frans Schalkwijk, Patrick Luyten, Theo Ingenhoven, Jack DekkerFrontiers in Psychology : 2021
-
Kerrin A. JacobsFrontiers in Psychiatry : 2022
-
Cesare Cavalera, Annalisa Boldrini, Alessia Antonella Merelli, Edoardo Squillari, Pierluigi Politi, Francesco Pagnini, Osmano OasiBMC Psychology : 2021